This petition was submitted during the 2019-2024 parliament
Petition Establish a Commission to investigate extortionate Car Insurance price rises
Car insurance prices have become increasingly more expensive since the Coronavirus pandemic, surpassing pre-pandemic average costs to insure cars despite a general reduction of road related deaths. Regulations at this time allow for consumer price gouging and cause hardship for many with no benefit.
More details
A comission should be organised to investigate the regulatory practices of car insurance pricing and to ensure of fair competition.
A commission should look at alternative models. For example, in four provinces of Canada car insurance is a government-owned and operated system, a similar system in the UK could not only provide a potential additional revenue stream for the government but also limit the financial hardship caused by purchasing 3rd party insurance from private companies which maintain primary responsibility to earnings of their shareholders.
This petition is closed This petition ran for 6 months
Government responded
This response was given on 22 January 2024
Insurance pricing is a commercial decision for insurers. The Financial Conduct Authority, as the independent regulator, requires insurance products to offer fair value and has powers to act.
Read the response in full
The Government is aware of the current increases in the cost of motor insurance for many households, as well as the challenges facing households due to the increased cost of living.
The Government does not prescribe the terms, conditions or price that insurance companies may set when offering insurance. Insurers make decisions about the terms on which they will offer cover following an assessment of the relevant risks. This is usually informed by the insurer’s claims experience and other industry-wide statistics. At present there are wider economic factors, such as the increased costs of materials and labour in supply chains, that are contributing to increases in claims costs and therefore insurance premiums.
The Government does not intend to intervene in these commercial decisions as this could damage competition in the market.
However, the Government is determined that insurance companies should treat customers fairly. The Financial Conduct Authority (FCA), as the independent regulator of financial services, has the strategic objective of ensuring that the markets it regulates function well. In general terms, it also does not prescribe the terms, conditions or prices set by insurers, but may take action to achieve its objectives. For example, in 2022 the FCA introduced rules to prevent firms charging higher renewal premiums that exploited loyal customers.
Under FCA rules, firms are required to ensure their products offer fair value (i.e. the price a consumer pays for a product or service must be reasonable compared to the overall benefits they can expect to receive). The FCA has been clear that it will be monitoring firms to make sure they are providing products that are fair value, and, where necessary, it will take action.
In addition to requiring insurance company’s products to offer fair value, the FCA has a statutory objective to promote effective competition in the interests of consumers. The FCA works towards this objective, as far as the work is compatible with advancing its other objectives. The FCA can also enforce against breaches of competition law for the provision of financial services generally, alongside the Competition and Markets Authority. All businesses, include insurers must comply with competition law.
Given the already existing remits and powers of the FCA and CMA, the Government does not intend to establish a Commission to investigate motor insurance premiums at the present time. The Government will continue to monitor the motor insurance market closely and continue to engage with both the regulators and the insurance sector.
HM Treasury
Related activity
MPs debate Government support for young drivers
MPs held a debate on Government support for young drivers on Tuesday 20 February in Westminster Hall. The debate was led by Carla Lockhart MP. Anthony Browne MP, Under-Secretary of State for Transport responded on behalf of the Government.
During the debate, MPs discussed barriers to driving for young people, including the cost of motor insurance, and the impact this can have.
Responding to the debate, the Government Minister acknowledged concerns about the cost of insurance, but said that insurance operates in a free market, and that the Government do not set the terms, conditions or prices that insurance companies set when offering motor insurance.
The Minister said that there is a strong regulatory regime in place, and that this needs to work to ensure markets work fairly and in the interests of consumers. He also said that Government officials regularly engage with representatives of the motor insurance industry on a number of matters, including the rise in premiums.
What is a Westminster Hall debate?
Westminster Hall is the second chamber of the House of Commons. Westminster Hall debates give MPs an opportunity to raise local and national issues and receive a response from a government minister. Westminster Hall debates are general debates that do not end in a vote.
Get involved in the work of the UK Parliament
Sign up to the Your UK Parliament newsletter for the latest information on how to get involved and make a difference.